New site. Forecasts become public on this site from Monday, November 16, 2026. Earlier forecasts come from our private, time-stamped logs and are marked as such.

The closing line beats us. Here is by how much.

We grade every forecast against the closing line, the sharpest public prediction of a game. In every sport we cover, our average miss is larger than the market's. Use these ratings to understand teams and games. Do not expect them to beat a sportsbook.

The Ledger

Us against the closing line, in public.

Every graded game

0.42

College basketball: the closing line's average miss was smaller by this much, on 295 games this season (10.13 against 9.71).

0.55

NBA: our average miss was smaller by this much, on 33 games this season (10.04 against 10.59).

0.27

College football: the closing line's average miss was smaller by this much, on 110 games this season (13.42 against 13.15).

0.15

NFL: the closing line's average miss was smaller by this much, on 100 games this season (9.37 against 9.22).

This season, game by game

Each finished game with a forecast made before the start. "Public" means that the forecast was on this site before the game started. "Private log" means that we logged it with a time stamp before the game, before this site existed.

SportForecastsGraded gamesWith a closeOur average missClosing line's
College basketballPublic2121 13.31 12.26
College basketballPrivate log394274 9.88 9.51
NBAPrivate log19133 10.04 10.59
College footballPrivate log484110 13.42 13.15
NFLPrivate log100100 9.37 9.22

In points. A miss is the distance between a forecast and the final margin. When a closing line is recorded, both averages use the same games. Without one, the "ours" value covers all graded games.

Past seasons

SportRatingOursClosing lineGapSampleTest type
College basketballPower, game margins 8.96 8.85 0.11 5,597 games with a closing line, 2023-24 In-sample
College basketballPower, game totals 13.16 12.92 0.24 5,597 games with a closing line, 2023-24 In-sample
College basketballPower, game margins 8.95 8.80 0.15 5,540 games with a closing line, 2024-25 In-sample
College basketballPower, game totals 13.02 12.63 0.39 5,540 games with a closing line, 2024-25 In-sample
College basketballPower, game margins 9.06 8.97 0.09 5,432 games with a closing line, 2025-26 In-sample
College basketballPower, game totals 13.91 13.44 0.47 5,432 games with a closing line, 2025-26 In-sample
NBAStrength 10.02 9.83 0.19 one season of the 5,281 games scored in 2022-23 to 2025-26, 2022-23 Walk-forward
NBAStrength 10.81 10.67 0.14 one season of the 5,281 games scored in 2022-23 to 2025-26, 2023-24 Walk-forward
NBAStrength 10.87 10.64 0.23 one season of the 5,281 games scored in 2022-23 to 2025-26, 2024-25 Walk-forward
NBAStrength 11.11 10.96 0.14 one season of the 5,281 games scored in 2022-23 to 2025-26, 2025-26 Walk-forward
College footballRating 12.43 12.00 0.43 2,883 FBS-vs-FBS games, 2022 to 2025 seasons Walk-forward
NFLRating 9.94 9.78 0.16 1,610 games, 2020 to 2025 regular seasons Walk-forward
NFLRating 10.25 10.04 0.22 56 games, 2026 weeks 7-10 (live, final games so far) Forward

Average miss on the final margin, in points, from backtests. In-sample tests use seasons that also helped build the model, so they flatter it. Walk-forward and holdout tests do not.

Did the line move toward our number?

SportTestMovement toward usGamesPeriodType
College basketballMargins: our margin 3 points or more from the morning spread (3 points)+0.83 points812026-11-03 to 2026-11-16Forward
College basketballTotals: our total 4 points or more from the morning total (4 points)+0.22 points612026-11-03 to 2026-11-16Forward
NBAMargins, gaps of 2 or more points against the line at tip - 3 h (median of 3 or more books) (2 points)+0.19 points2,4792022-23 to 2025-26Walk-forward
NBAMargins, gaps of 2 or more points against the line at tip - 3 h (Pinnacle) (2 points)+0.17 points2,4902022-23 to 2025-26Walk-forward
College footballSpreads, entries with The Odds API lines at entry and close (any nonzero gap)−0.08 points182026-10-29 to 2026-11-15Forward
NFLEarly-week line value against Pinnacle (not an edge: the pre-registered test failed)+0.17 points5432024 and 2025 regular seasonsHoldout

A positive number means the market moved toward our forecast between the time we logged it and the close. It is a sign that the forecast carries information. It is not a profit figure, and it does not include the sportsbook's margin.

How much of the season is graded

A forecast can only be graded against the close if we recorded a closing line for that game. This is the share we caught, so you can see what the averages above leave out.

College basketball
415 finished games: 415 with a forecast before the start, 295 with a closing line (71%).
NBA
192 finished games: 191 with a forecast before the start, 33 with a closing line (17%).
College football
484 finished games: 484 with a forecast before the start, 110 with a closing line (23%).
NFL
100 finished games: 100 with a forecast before the start, 100 with a closing line (100%).

Some days have no forecast, for example during a computer outage from November 4 to November 10, 2026. Games without a forecast made before the start are not graded.

Every game, week by week

Each week we list every finished game: our forecast, the closing line, the result and who was closer.

College basketball · NBA · College football · NFL

Take the whole record

Every graded forecast, with its time stamp, the result, our miss and the closing line's miss.

Download as CSV · Open as JSON